Get Your Quote

Fiberglass Doors Vs. Wood Doors – A Side-By-Side Comparison

When it comes to choosing between fiberglass and wood for your doors, the decision can be challenging. 

Both materials have their unique advantages and potential drawbacks. However, it’s crucial to factor in aspects such as longevity, maintenance, insulation values, and cost. In a head-to-head comparison, fiberglass doors generally edge out wood doors.

Though they may lack the classic charm of genuine wood, fiberglass doors offer superior durability, lower maintenance requirements, and better insulation, making them a more cost-effective choice in the long run. Let’s delve deeper into this comparison to provide you with a clear picture.

Fiberglass Doors Vs Wood Doors side by side For Homes

Key Takeaways

  • Durability and Maintenance: Fiberglass doors trump wood doors with their resistance to warping and low maintenance needs, ensuring a cost-effective, long-lasting investment.
  • Energy Efficiency: Fiberglass doors excel in thermal insulation, with insulating foam and polyurethane cores contributing to stable indoor temperatures and potential energy savings.
  • Cost Considerations: While initial costs for fiberglass doors may be higher, their durability and energy efficiency make them a more economical choice in the long run compared to wood doors.
  • Aesthetics and Style Options: Wood doors offer timeless beauty, but fiberglass doors are catching up in mimicking the classic wood look, providing a range of styles and colors for diverse preferences.
  • Manufacturers in Tennessee: Top choices for fiberglass doors include Therma-Tru, Masonite, Plastpro, ProVia, and JELD-WEN. For wood doors, consider Graham Wood Doors, Eggers Industries, VT Industries, and TruStile Doors in Tennessee.

Understanding Fiberglass Doors

Fiberglass doors, a remarkable innovation in the door industry, offer an appealing blend of resilience, aesthetics, and energy efficiency. Designed to imitate the warmth and texture of traditional wood, these doors stand up remarkably well to the elements without the risk of warping, cracking, or rotting.

Their superior insulating properties make them a preferred choice for homeowners seeking to optimize energy consumption. Furthermore, their minimal maintenance demands and long lifespan make them a cost-effective investment for your home.

Blue Fiberglass Door And Windows Front of House

  • Pros and Cons Of Fiberglass Doors
  • Durability: Fiberglass doors are resilient and resistant to warping, rotting, and rusting, ensuring a long lifespan.
  • Insulation: These doors have excellent thermal insulation, which can significantly reduce energy costs in your home.
  • Maintenance: Fiberglass doors require minimal upkeep, saving you time and money on regular maintenance and repairs.
  • Aesthetics: Despite advances in design, fiberglass doors may not fully mimic the rich, classic look of real wood.
  • Cost: While cost-effective in the long run, the initial cost of fiberglass doors can be higher than wooden ones.
  • Repairs: When damaged, fiberglass doors can be difficult and expensive to repair compared to wood doors.

What Fiberglass Doors Are Made From

Fiberglass doors are crafted using comprehensive engineering and specialized materials to offer their exceptional durability and insulation properties. The composition of these doors is what sets them apart and contributes to their superior performance.

  • Fiberglass: The name itself suggests that fiberglass is the primary material used. This durable, lightweight material is resistant to many of the wear-and-tear issues that wood doors face.
  • Insulating Foam: A core of insulating foam is often used in fiberglass doors, enhancing their energy efficiency.
  • Reinforced Frame: The frame is typically made from reinforced composite material or steel for added strength and stability.
  • Polyurethane Cores: Some fiberglass doors may also feature a polyurethane core, which boosts insulation and helps maintain an ideal indoor temperature.
  • Composite Stiles: These are essentially the vertical elements of the door, made from a composite material that prevents warping and increases the door's lifespan.

  • Fiberglass Doors - Durability & Longevity
Fiberglass doors can last up to 50 years or more, thanks in large part to their resistance to many common forms of damage such as warping, rusting, and rotting. However, to ensure your door reaches this longevity, here are some maintenance tips:
  • Regular Cleaning: Keep the door clean by regularly wiping it with a soft, damp cloth. Avoid using abrasive cleaners that can damage the surface.
  • Sealing: Ensure the door is properly sealed. This not only helps protect the door from moisture and drafts but also contributes to its energy efficiency.
  • Weatherstripping: Maintain the door's weatherstripping to prevent drafts and energy loss. Replace it as needed.
  • Regular Inspections: Check your door regularly for signs of damage. Early detection can prevent minor issues from turning into major ones.
  • Professional Repairs: If your door is damaged, it's generally best to hire professionals to repair it. Such repairs can be complicated and doing them incorrectly can further damage the door.

By following these simple maintenance tips, you can extend the lifespan of your fiberglass door and keep it looking great for many years to come.

  • Fiberglass Doors - Energy Efficiency

Fiberglass entry doors are highly energy-efficient, effectively withstanding weather changes. Their unique construction with insulating foam and polyurethane cores ensures a stable indoor environment. The insulating foam acts as a thermal barrier, while the polyurethane core provides additional insulation, keeping your home warm in winter and cool in summer.

These features make fiberglass doors cost-effective by reducing energy bills. However, proper installation and sealing are crucial to prevent drafts and energy loss, maximizing their efficiency.

  • Fiberglass Doors - Costs

Fiberglass doors, while being a higher initial investment, can be quite cost-effective in the long run due to their low maintenance, durability, and energy efficiency features. On average, fiberglass doors cost may range from $200 to $2000, depending on the brand, model, and customization options. The cost can increase if you opt for better insulation or additional features such as impact resistance or special finishes.

  • Therma-Tru: This brand is considered a pioneer in the fiberglass door industry and is known for the quality, selection, and style of its products.
  • Masonite: Masonite produces energy-efficient fiberglass doors that are both aesthetically pleasing and highly durable.
  • Plastpro: Plastpro offers a wide range of door styles with excellent insulation properties.
  • ProVia: ProVia is known for its attention to detail and handcrafted durability, making its doors a popular choice for homeowners.
  • JELD-WEN: This manufacturer is a global leader in the industry and offers a comprehensive range of fiberglass doors to fit various architectural styles and preferences.

These manufacturers are all reputable companies that offer a variety of styles, finishes, and customization options to cater to diverse consumer needs. Be sure to refer to their respective websites for more information on their product range and pricing.

Fiberglass exterior doors are available in a wide range of styles and colors to match any architectural aesthetic or homeowner’s personal taste. Here are some common options:

Understanding Wood Doors

Wood doors are a classic choice, admired for their timeless beauty and natural aesthetic. They are highly customizable and come in a diverse range of styles and finishes, perfectly adaptable to any architectural design or personal preference.

Renowned for their robustness and sound-dampening qualities, they deliver a sense of warmth, elegance, and rich character to any home’s entrance. However, understanding their benefits, maintenance needs, cost implications, and the various styles available is crucial for homeowners considering this option.

Light Blue Wood Door Front of House

  • Pros and Cons of Wood Doors
  • Aesthetics: Wood doors offer a timeless, classic appeal that adds a rich, warm touch to any home.
  • Versatility: With a wide range of species, stains, and finishes available, wood doors can be customized to suit any style.
  • Repairability: Damages such as scratches or dents can be easily repaired or refinished on a wooden door.
  • Maintenance: Wood doors require regular maintenance, like sealing and staining, to prevent warping, rotting, or termite damage.
  • Durability: Unlike fiberglass, wood doors can suffer from weather-induced damages, affecting their durability and longevity.
  • Cost: High-quality wood doors can come with a hefty price tag, especially for exotic wood species.

  • What Wood Doors can be Made From
Wood doors are the epitome of classic beauty and enduring charm. They lend a cozy and inviting ambiance to any home, boasting a natural texture that is hard to replicate. Despite their need for more regular maintenance, many homeowners still prefer them for their authenticity and versatility.
  • Solid Wood: The primary material used in wood doors is solid wood, often hardwoods like mahogany or oak, for their strength and aesthetics.
  • Plywood or MDF: In some cases, wood doors may also be crafted from layers of plywood or Medium Density Fiberboard (MDF) to resist warping and cracking.
  • Veneer: This is a thin slice of real wood adhered to the surface of the door, providing the look and feel of a solid wood door without the high cost and maintenance.
  • Stiles and Rails: These are the framework of the door, usually made from solid wood for structural integrity.
  • Glass Inserts: In some designs, glass inserts or panels might be used to enhance aesthetics and allow natural light into the home.

  • Wood Doors - Durability & Longevity

To extend the lifespan of your wood door, consider the following tips:

  • Regular Maintenance: Unlike fiberglass doors, wood doors require more intensive upkeep. Regularly stain or paint your door to protect it from the elements and to preserve its appearance.
  • Sealing: Apply a high-quality sealant to prevent moisture penetration, which can lead to rotting or warping. Check the sealant often for signs of wear or cracking and reapply as necessary.
  • Cleaning: Regularly clean your door using a mild detergent and a soft cloth to prevent the build-up of dirt and grime.
  • Inspections: Regularly inspect your door for signs of damage, such as cracking, warping, or termite infestation. Early detection and proper treatment can save your door from severe damage.
  • Weatherstripping: Weatherstripping protects your door from drafts and energy loss, but it can wear out over time. Check it regularly and replace it when necessary.
  • Professional Repairs: If your door has suffered significant damage, consider hiring a professional to repair it. DIY repairs may not adequately address the issue and may lead to further damage down the line.

By adhering to these practices, you can help ensure that your wood door remains a beautiful and functional element of your home for many years to come.

  • Wood Doors - Energy Efficiency

Wood exterior doors, especially those made from genuine hardwood, offer both aesthetic appeal and energy efficiency. Their natural insulating properties help maintain indoor temperatures, acting as a barrier against external weather conditions.

The type of wood and construction impact their efficiency. Hardwoods generally provide better insulation than softwoods, and solid wood doors outperform those made from mixed materials. However, proper installation and sealing are crucial. Poor installation can lead to drafts and increased energy costs, so professional installation and regular maintenance are essential for optimal energy efficiency.

  • Wood Doors Costs

The cost of fiberglass wood doors varies greatly depending on their size, style, and the manufacturer. On average, they range from $200 to $2,500. Fiberglass doors mimic the look and feel of real wood, but they are more durable and require less maintenance. They are an economical alternative to traditional wood doors, especially for those on a tight budget.

When considering wood doors, it’s important to research reputable manufacturers. Below are the top 5 wood door manufacturers in Tennessee:

  • Graham Wood Doors: Graham has a long-standing reputation for crafting high-quality architectural wood doors. Their durable and stylish doors are suitable for a variety of applications.
  • Eggers Industries: Eggers is known for their commitment to sustainability and craftsmanship. They offer a wide range of high-quality wood and veneer doors.
  • VT Industries: VT Industries specializes in commercial and architectural wood doors. They offer a variety of styles and finishes to suit different design preferences.
  • Marshfield Door Systems: Marshfield offers custom architectural wood doors that combine aesthetics and functionality. Their doors are ideal for both commercial and residential properties.
  • TruStile Doors: TruStile sets the standard for high quality and design flexibility. Their doors are customizable, offering a unique blend of style and durability.
Wood doors come in a vast array of styles and colors, accommodating every homeowner’s aesthetic preferences and architectural requirements. Here are some popular options:

Fiberglass Doors Vs. Wooden Doors Comparison Table

Aspect Fiberglass Doors Wooden Doors
Cost Generally cheaper, ranging from $200 to $2,500. More expensive, depending on the choice of wood and craftsmanship.
Durability Very durable and highly resistant to warping and rotting. Requires less maintenance. Susceptible to natural elements, may warp and decay over time. Requires regular maintenance.
Energy Efficiency Good insulating properties, but depends on the construction and sealing. Excellent insulating properties due to natural qualities of wood, but depends on the type of wood and proper installation.
Best For Suitable for both interior and exterior applications. Typically used for exterior applications, but can also be used interiorly for a rustic appeal.

More to read on the topic: Metal Doors Vs Wood Doors – Which is Better?

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Fiberglass and Wood Doors

When deciding between fiberglass and wood doors, it is important to take into consideration various factors that will impact not only the appearance of your home but also its functionality and overall energy efficiency.
  • Aesthetic Preferences
Both fiberglass and wood doors offer a wide array of styles, colors, and finishes. Your choice may ultimately boil down to the aesthetic that you are looking to achieve.
  • Budget
Fiberglass doors are generally cheaper, making them a good choice for homeowners on a budget. However, if you’re willing to invest more for the natural, warm look that wood doors provide, then a wooden door may be worth considering.
  • Maintenance
Wood doors require more maintenance as they are susceptible to warping and rotting over time, while fiberglass doors are more durable and need less upkeep.
  • Energy Efficiency
Both types have good insulating properties, but this largely depends on the door’s construction and sealing. Solid wood doors might provide better insulation than those made from a combination of wood and other materials.
  • Location
Depending on your geographical location and the local climate, one type of door may perform better than the other. For instance, in areas prone to high humidity or rapid temperature changes, fiberglass doors may be a better option due to their high resistance to warping and rotting.
  • Installation and Lifespan
Both types require professional installation to ensure optimal energy efficiency. However, fiberglass doors typically have a longer lifespan, providing a better long-term investment.

More to read about doors: Door Knobs vs. Handles

Fiberglass Doors Vs. Wood Doors FAQs

While fiberglass doors have many advantages, there are a few potential downsides to consider.

First, although they mimic the appearance of real wood, the synthetic nature of fiberglass might not appeal to those who prefer the natural warmth and texture of real wood.

Second, low-quality fiberglass doors can fade over time under direct sunlight, requiring the need for repainting or refinishing.

Lastly, while fiberglass doors are generally more durable than their wooden counterparts, they are not completely immune to damage – extreme impact can cause cracking or denting on their surface.

Fiberglass doors are often considered better due to their durability, cost-effectiveness, and low maintenance requirements. Unlike wood doors, they are resistant to warping, rotting, and termite damage.

Their insulating properties are excellent, making them energy-efficient and suitable for various weather conditions. Furthermore, they can convincingly mimic the appearance of real wood, offering aesthetic appeal. While initial costs may be higher, the long-term maintenance costs are significantly lower due to their durability and resistance to common issues plaguing wood doors.

Fiberglass doors are widely recognized for their excellent quality due to their durability, strength, and energy efficiency. They are designed to withstand harsh weather conditions and resist common problems associated with wood doors like warping, rotting, and termite damage.

Additionally, the insulating properties of fiberglass doors make them highly energy efficient, leading to potential savings on energy costs.

Furthermore, they come in a variety of styles, colors, and finishes, and can convincingly mimic the appearance of real wood, thereby providing both functional and aesthetic benefits. It’s essential, however, to ensure that you choose a high-quality fiberglass door as lower quality options may not offer the same level of benefits.

Fiberglass doors typically have a long lifespan, often exceeding 20 years with proper care and maintenance. Their longevity can be attributed to their inherent durability, resistance to warping and rotting, and their ability to withstand various weather conditions.

It’s important to note, however, that the lifespan of a fiberglass door can vary depending on factors such as the quality of the door, the harshness of the local climate, and the level of care and maintenance provided.

Turn To Gallatin's Superior Door Installation Service

For superior door installation services, reach out to us at Windows For Life. We offer professional installation of your choice of doors and collaborate with the best brands in the industry. Call us today at (615) 861-2315, and let’s get started on enhancing the aesthetic appeal, efficiency, and security of your home.

Talk to an Expert